Thursday, January 27, 2011

Truth in SOTU Infographics?

[see this site for the original criticism]
bad infographic

I can't believe such a high profile infographic would be less than truthful!

Nah, I'm just being silly. Infographics have no relation at all to truth. They just trick people into thinking they are seeing real facts because they resemble that statistics stuff. Which is math so it must be right. Or something. But it's not scary like math is. It's pretty like art. We like art. And shiny. And pudding. Mmmmm, pudding.

In this case, apparently they scaled the diameter, not the area. Perhaps this was unintentional. Regardless of the technical accuracy, actual visual comparisons, and therefore comprehension, are not facilitated because it very hard to compare areas unless they are overlapping (and often not even then). Some times circles are a good way to display secondary information where larger or smaller is much more important than how much larger. For this application there are far more useful ways to comunicate the same information. The most obvious is a bar chart. To eliminate the unsightly gridlines and make it easier to see multiples the bars could be segmented (small gaps every $2 trillion perhaps).

But this would be a bar chart, not an infographic and therefore appear "technical". Circles with pretty gradients look more aesthetic even if they do obfuscate the very information they purportedly convey.

And we do live in a world that values style over substance.

Saturday, January 1, 2011

The Problem with Laws

Actions have consequences.
Acts of congress have unintended consequences.

Which is why I'm not thrilled that the outgoing 111th Congress has been so prolific.

As bureaucrats and analysts continue to pore over the thousands of pages of new law this year they will discover new taxes and new regulations. Among the millions of interactions with existing law some will be problematical and some will be bizarre.

And some provisions will have the exact opposite effect of that intended. Which is the theme of this video from reason.tv

Making good law is hard.

And quantity is no substitute for quality.

Frist Post!

EXCOGITATE, vb. to consider or think something out carefully and thoroughly

Having capitulated to peer pressure, I have resigned myself to attempting to maintain a blog for a year. The plan is to foist pretentious posts with lots of big words on an unsuspecting public whenever I'm not having an existential crisis (which is pretty often these days). Or maybe I'll just try to start interesting discussions on topics ranging from Politics, to my problems with church, to technology and sociology.

I'll try to put up one essay a month plus an couple of posts commenting on only the most interesting stuff I run into on the internets.

Because I couldn't decide on a platform, I'm going to just do both blogger and tumblr for now. (the other one is at excogitator.tumblr.com)

And there's still the ol twitter @marshalldsmith.